Cowboy Club Sandwich

The Cowboy Club Sandwich is a hearty, layered sandwich that brings together smoky bacon, tender chicken, ripe avocado, crisp lettuce, and juicy tomato. It grew from the classic club sandwich and the bold flavors of western cookouts. People loved it because it gives a full meal in one hand. The first thing you notice is the smell: warm buttered sourdough and hot bacon fill the air. Then the taste hits: salty bacon, creamy avocado, tangy barbecue sauce, melted cheddar, and mild chicken make a balanced mix. The texture is part of the joy. Toasted bread gives a clear crunch, lettuce adds fresh snap, avocado adds soft cream, and cheese melts into the warm layers. It looks rich when you cut it. You see neat, colorful layers that make your mouth water. This sandwich became a classic because it is simple, filling, and easy to share. Home cooks and diners both love it. You can finish it fast for lunch or make it for a casual dinner with friends. This version keeps the recipe plain and reliable. It uses common pantry items and small hands-on time. If you enjoy robust sandwiches, also try the classic Italian muffuletta sandwich for another bright idea. The Cowboy Club makes you hungry and ready to cook. Read on to learn how to build each layer, how to toast bread just right, and how to pick the best avocado so your sandwich turns out perfect every time. You will enjoy every bite. Make it today and share.

Why make this recipe

• Easy to make. This sandwich uses simple steps like cooking bacon and toasting bread. A new cook can follow it well.
• Fast cook time. You can have it ready in about 20 minutes if you use cooked chicken. It is great for quick lunch or fast dinner.
• Uses pantry staples. Most ingredients are common: bread, bacon, mayo, cheese, lettuce, tomato, and avocado.
• Flexible and cost smart. Swap or skip items to fit your budget or diet. You can use leftover chicken to save money.
• Crowd pleaser. The mix of smoke, cheese, cream, and crunch makes most people happy at a party or a family meal.

This version focuses on balance. The bbq sauce adds a light tang that lifts the sandwich. Using sourdough gives a strong base so the sandwich does not get soggy fast. The double layering of ingredients makes each bite full but tidy.

How to make Cowboy Club Sandwich

Start with a plan. The main aim is to build hot and cold layers that stay pleasant when you bite. We crisp bacon to add crunch and smoke. We toast bread with butter to add structure and a warm base. We layer cool items like avocado and lettuce between warm cheese and chicken so the sandwich keeps contrast.

Cook bacon until it is crisp but not burnt. Crisp bacon gives a good snap and avoids limp strips that flop when you bite. Toast sourdough with butter until it is golden on both sides. The golden toast should feel firm when you press it. Spread mayonnaise thinly to add moisture and a glossy barrier so the bread does not soak up wet juices from tomato. Place lettuce and tomato next for a fresh layer. Add sliced avocado for creamy mouthfeel. Warm the cooked chicken slightly so it is not cold; warm chicken helps the cheese melt slowly. Add cheese and bacon last on that layer so the heat from the chicken and toast softens the cheddar.

If you want a smaller party version, try a linked idea for small sandwiches like the cowboy sliders recipe. The order of layers matters: firm base, then a wet-resistant spread, then crisp and soft items, then protein and cheese for warmth, then top bread. This order keeps the sandwich tidy and tasty.

Ingredients

• 6 slices thick-cut Bacon
• 4 oz cooked Chicken breast
• 1 ripe Avocado
• 4 leaves Romaine lettuce
• 2 medium Tomatoes
• 2 tbsp Bbq sauce
• 2 tbsp Mayonnaise
• Salt and pepper to taste
• 4 hearty slices Sourdough bread
• 1 tbsp Butter
• 4 slices Cheddar cheese

Choose the best items by feel and look. Pick thick-cut bacon that is even in fat and meat. Use cooked chicken that is moist, not dry; rotisserie chicken is a good, quick choice. Select an avocado that gives slightly to gentle pressure but is not mushy. Choose firm, bright-red tomatoes and crisp romaine leaves. For bread, pick dense sourdough that holds up to wet fillings. Good cheddar melts well and adds sharp flavor.

Substitutions: For a dairy-free option, use dairy-free cheese and vegan mayo. For low-carb, swap sourdough for large lettuce leaves or low-carb bread. For a vegetarian version, replace chicken and bacon with grilled portobello or smoked tofu and use plant-based bacon.

Directions

1. Cook the bacon until crispy and set aside.

   • Heat a skillet over medium heat. Lay bacon strips flat. You should hear a steady sizzle. Cook for about 6–10 minutes, turning so both sides brown evenly. The bacon will shrink and curl slightly. Aim for even deep brown with no burnt black spots. Remove and drain on paper towels. The bacon should feel crisp and snap when you bend it.

2. Toast the sourdough bread with butter until golden brown.

   • Spread butter on one side of each slice. In a clean pan over medium heat, place slices butter-side down. Toast until the bottom is deep gold, about 2–3 minutes. Flip and toast the other side. Visual cue: the crust will darken but not burn. The bread should sound firm when tapped and feel warm and crisp.

3. Spread mayonnaise on one slice of bread and layer with lettuce, tomatoes, avocado, chicken, bacon, and cheddar cheese.

   • Use about a teaspoon of mayo per slice and spread evenly to the edges. Place romaine so it lies flat and adds a green bed. Add tomato slices that are bright and juicy; a good cut shows seeds but not a pool of juice. Add slices of avocado that are smooth and creamy. Place the cooked chicken on top; if the chicken is cold, heat it briefly so the cheese begins to soften. Add bacon in neat strips. Lay cheddar slices last; they will warm and melt slightly when the sandwich is closed.

4. Add another slice of bread and repeat the layering process, finishing with the final slice of bread on top.

   • Build a second layer the same way if you want a double-decker sandwich. Press lightly but firmly so the layers stick together. Visual cue: when you look at the side you should see clear, even bands of color and texture.

5. Cut the sandwich in half and secure with toothpicks if desired.

   • Use a sharp knife and a single, confident stroke. The sandwich should cut cleanly if the bread is well toasted. Insert toothpicks at an angle if you will serve upright. The cut face should show tidy layers and slight melting of cheese.

6. Serve with your choice of side.

   • Let the sandwich sit for one minute on the cut side so cheese sets slightly. Serve warm with a crisp side. The smell will be strong with butter and bacon. Each bite should give a mix of crunch, cream, and savory meat.

How to serve Cowboy Club Sandwich

• Side dishes: Serve with kettle chips, sweet potato fries, or a simple slaw for crunch and brightness. A small pickle on the side adds sharp contrast.
• Drink pairings: Pair with an iced tea or a cold lager for a classic match. For a non-alcohol option, a sparkling lemonade or cola works well.
• Plate like a pro: Use a white plate, place the sandwich halves leaning against each other, and stack a small pile of fries to one side. Add a sprig of parsley or a pickle spear for color. Wipe the plate edge clean for a tidy look.
• Family style: Cut into four pieces and serve on a wooden board so guests can grab their share.

How to store Cowboy Club Sandwich

Short-term (fridge): Wrap the sandwich halves tightly in plastic wrap or place in an airtight container. Keep in the fridge up to 24 hours for best texture. Note: the avocado will brown over time and the bread may soften.

Long-term (freezer): It is not ideal to freeze a fully built sandwich because lettuce and tomato lose texture. You can freeze cooked bacon and cooked chicken separately in sealed bags for up to 2 months. Freeze slices of cheddar and bread if you need to store them.

Best way to reheat: To reheat a built sandwich, preheat an oven to 350°F (175°C). Wrap the sandwich in foil and heat for 10–12 minutes until warm. Open the foil for the last 2 minutes to crisp the bread. For one half, use a toaster oven on medium for 4–6 minutes. To avoid sogginess, remove lettuce and tomato before reheating, then add fresh slices after warming.

Tips to make Cowboy Club Sandwich

• Dry your tomato and lettuce well. Wet greens or tomatoes make the bread soggy fast.
• Slightly undercook bacon if you will reheat; it will crisp more when warmed with the sandwich.
• Use room temperature or slightly warm chicken so the cheese melts without overcooking the bread.
• Slice avocado thinly and press lemon on it to slow browning.
• Toast bread well and let it cool 30 seconds before spreading mayo to avoid melting and sliding.
• Use a sharp serrated knife for clean cuts through layers.
• Layer cheese near warm protein to help it melt evenly without microwaving.

Variation

• Make it Spicy: Add sliced jalapeños, swap bbq for chipotle sauce, and use pepper jack instead of cheddar.
• The Healthy Version: Use whole grain or low-carb bread, swap bacon for turkey bacon or tempeh bacon, and use Greek yogurt mixed with mayo for a lighter spread.
• The Deluxe Version: Add caramelized onions, smoked gouda, and a drizzle of honey mustard. Use grilled chicken breast with a light rub for deeper flavor.
• Vegetarian Twist: Replace chicken and bacon with grilled portobello and roasted red peppers. Use vegan cheese if desired.

FAQs

Q: Can I use raw chicken?
A: Not in this recipe. The list calls for cooked chicken breast. If you start with raw chicken, cook it fully (to 165°F / 74°C) by grilling or pan-searing, then slice thin before adding.

Q: Why is my sandwich soggy?
A: Sogginess often comes from wet tomato or lettuce and too little toast. Pat produce dry, toast the bread well, and spread mayonnaise as a barrier between bread and wet fillings.

Q: Can I make the sandwich ahead of time?
A: You can prep ingredients ahead. Cook bacon and chicken in advance and store separately. Assemble just before serving for best texture. If you must assemble early, skip avocado and tomato until ready.

Q: How do I keep avocado from turning brown?
A: Slice avocado right before use or toss slices with a few drops of lemon or lime juice. Keep slices snug between other layers and serve soon.

Q: What is the best bread to use?
A: Hearty sourdough works best because it holds all layers and adds tang. Thick-cut bread resists sogginess and gives a good crunch when toasted.

Conclusion

For a home cook’s take on a hearty layered sandwich similar to this, read the detailed home recipe at Cowboy Club Sandwich – I Am Homesteader. To learn about the restaurant history and original menu ideas, visit Cowboy Club Grille & Spirits – Uptown, Sedona, AZ.

Print